Neither WhatsApp nor The Guardianare having a good day.
The UK-based newspaper published a scathing exclusive report early Friday morning, purporting to reveal disturbing news about the encryption used by WhatsApp's, the Facebook-owned messaging service. Almost as soon as the article went live, however, security experts took to the internet to publicly question the nature of its claims.
Late in the day Friday, Open Whisper Systems, the team behind the end-to-end encryption service used by WhatsApp and secure messaging client Signal, published a blog post in response to the article. The post refuted The Guardian's claims at length, expressing the team's disappointment with the way in which the news was reported.
SEE ALSO:Older smartphones get locked out of WhatsAppAccording to The Guardian's article, WhatsApp has a glaring security flaw in the manner its end-to-end encryption is set up, which creates a wide-open backdoor which "allows snooping" by Facebook — and, by extension, government agencies or others who might gain access to it by legitimate or nefarious means.
The Guardianstory reports that WhatsApp's encryption is vulnerable when a user sends a message to a contact who is offline. When that happens, the end-to-end encryption is, in a sense, broken, since one of the ends no longer exists. In that case, the service creates a new set of encryption keys for the offline user so the message can they can still get it when they come back online. (For a primer on encryption, check out this helpful video or view it at the bottom of this post.)
However, WhatsApp doesn't alert either the sender or the recipient about of the change, and the messages are caught in a kind of limbo in the meantime, the security of which is unclear -- at least until the recipient comes back online. According to the Guardian, this "effectively allows WhatsApp to intercept and read users’ messages."
By comparison, Signal doesn't automatically resend offline messages like WhatsApp does, theoretically making those messages more secure.
Information security experts were turned off by the article. Complaining on Twitter, they were critical ofThe Guardian's reporting. Frederic Jacobs, who actually worked on Signal with Open Whisper Systems, the service's developer, even added his voice to the discussion:
It's ridiculous that this is presented as a backdoor. If you don't verify keys, authenticity of keys is not guaranteed. Well known fact.
— Frederic Jacobs (@FredericJacobs) January 13, 2017
The Guardianreport cited UC Berkely PhD student Tobias Boelter as having discovered the backdoor and claimed to have an "exclusive" on his findings. But that's not quite true.
As reported, Boelter notified Facebook of the vulnerability back in April 2016. The company then called the issue "expected behavior," confirming the existence of the issue and admitting it to be a feature of the service instead of a "backdoor," telling him "...for now it's not something we're actively working on changing."
In addition to contacting Facebook, Boelter detailed his findings on the vulnerability in a blog post. It wasn't published on an outlet like The Guardian— but Boelter's reports on the subject have been online for the better part of a year.
When contacted by Mashablevia email, Boelter clarified his role in the report. "I gave a 5-minute lightning talk at 33c3 in Hamburg on December 30, 2016 and was contacted by a reporter working for the Guardian afterwards," he said.
Following the article's publication, Boelter posted on the topic once again, discussing the nature of the issue and admitting the different interpretation of what it represents to end users.
After reaching out to a WhatsApp spokesperson for comment, Mashablereceived this response:
The Guardianposted a story this morning claiming that an intentional design decision in WhatsApp that prevents people from losing millions of messages is a “backdoor” allowing governments to force WhatsApp to decrypt message streams. This claim is false [emphasis theirs].
WhatsApp does not give governments a “backdoor” into its systems and would fight any government request to create a backdoor. The design decision referenced in the Guardianstory prevents millions of messages from being lost, and WhatsApp offers people security notifications to alert them to potential security risks. WhatsApp published a technical white paper on its encryption design, and has been transparent about the government requests it receives, publishing data about those requests in the Facebook Government Requests Report.
Later in the day, co-founder of WhatsApp Brian Acton posted a direct response on Reddit, again calling the story "false" and emphatically stating, "WhatsApp would fight any government request to create a backdoor."
In WhatsApp's white paper describing the service, it explicitly states, "WhatsApp servers do not have access to the private keys of WhatsApp users, and WhatsApp users have the option to verify keys in order to ensure the integrity of their communication."
Whether or not this so-called "backdoor" is an issue or a feature depends on your interpretation. In any case, it's probably the best thing to happen to Signal lately.
TopicsCybersecurityWhatsApp
(责任编辑：休閑)
Nancy Pelosi warns colleagues after info hackedApple's SiriThis quirky new tTwitter now lets you search for emojiPlayStation Now game streaming is coming to PCWe asked linguists if Donald Trump speaks like that on purpose
Donald Trump may do a good "drunk uncle at Thanksgiving" impersonation at his rallies, but amid all
...[详细]Finally, the VR esports tournament Oculus gamers have been waiting for
I have a confession to make: I'm addicted to playing 。 The Unspoken 。virtual reality game on the Oculu
...[详细]Bye rosé! Blue prosecco is this summer's go
Since 2017 has been the Year of the Unicorn, we might as well go that same route with our trendy sum
...[详细]Gorillaz will be headed to a television screen near you soon
Your favorite virtual band isn't going away for another seven years anytime soon.。 Come 2018, Gorill
...[详细]This weird squid looks like it has googly eyes, guys
Internet, meet your new spirit animal.。Scientists aboard the research vessel the E/V Nautilus, off t
...[详细]'Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2' struggles to measure up to the original, say critics
As a sequel to one of the best movies ever to come out of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Guardians o
...[详细]Arnold Schwarzenegger gleefully photobombs tourists in Paris
If there's one thing Arnold Schwarzenegger truly loves, it's exploring new cities on his bicycle.。He
...[详细]'Overwatch' pro goes on racist tirade on stream, destroys his own career
Overwatch
。player Matt "Dellor" Vaughn caused his title to change from pro to former pro over the wee
...[详细]MashReads Podcast: What makes a good summer read?
Summer is coming to a close and that means one thing -- last-minute vacations! 。SEE ALSO:'Ice Cream B
...[详细]The 10 things I want most from Kim and Kanye's kids collection as an adult woman
As a taxpaying citizen whose style icon is North West, I'm pretty psyched about the Kimye kids' klot
...[详细]Olympian celebrates by ordering an intimidating amount of McDonald's
Ed Sheeran shuts down rumours he's quitting music in 1 no