President Trump may have just dramatically slashed the size of two national monuments in Utah, but America's 59 national parks -- as well as over 270 other national park sites -- cannot be unilaterally downsized by Trump or any other president.
The legal reason is simple and inarguable:
"National parks can only be established by Congress, and everyone agrees they can only be undone, if at all, by Congress," Holly Doremus, a natural resources law expert at University of California, Berkeley, told Mashablein an email.
SEE ALSO:Photos of the majestic public lands Trump just opened to drilling and huntingNational monuments -- like Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante -- are a different story. Combined, Trump reduced both protected lands by nearly 2 million acres combined. Bears Ears was reduced in size by over 80 percent.
Unlike national parks or other national park sites -- places like national rivers, national preserves, and national seashores -- national monuments are established by the president, who wields the unilateral power to protect places of historic or scientific interest from resource extraction and development. This presidential power is granted by the 1906 Antiquities Act and was first employed by the conservation-minded president Theodore Roosevelt to establish Devils Tower National Monument in Wyoming, also in 1906.
But while presidents can establish a national monument, it's doubtful -- though still arguable-- they can change monument boundaries, like Congress can. Because the Trump administration just did this, they have now entered murky legal territory.
"Congress can certainly undo a national monument designation," said Doremus. "It is disputed whether the president can unilaterally do so. Most natural resource scholars think not."
Theodore Roosevelt used the Antiquities Act to protect Devil's Tower National Monument in 1906.Credit: national park serviceA review of the matter, published earlier this year by two natural resource lawyers in The Virginia Law Review, supports this belief. They argue that only Congress has the power to "downsize" a national monument, just like only Congress can nix or dissolve a national monument. They write:
If the President cannot abolish a national monument because Congress did not delegate that authority to the President, it follows that the President also lacks the power to downsize or loosen the protections afforded to a monument.
Still, no president has ever cut the boundaries of a national monument to such an extreme degree and then been challenged in court. The authors add:
Importantly though, no Presidential decision to reduce the size of a national monument has ever been tested in court, and so no court has ever ruled on the legality of such an action.
Until this gets settled, it's possible the Trump administration will alter or downsize other national monuments. In a once-secret memo given to the president in August, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke recommended that four national monuments be downsized and six others altered.
National monuments like Bears Ears are not protected on a president's whim: They are typically reviewed for years and seek public input to confirm their natural and cultural significance, as President Obama articulated in December 2016:
"Following years of public input and various proposals to protect both of these areas, including legislation and a proposal from tribal governments in and around Utah, these monuments will protect places that a wide range of stakeholders all agree are worthy of protection."
TopicsDonald Trump
(责任编辑：百科)
Visualizing July's astounding global temperature records
NES Classics are coming back to stores in June
Review: Xiaomi Mi Electric Scooter is all over the roads for a reason
Deadpool's 'no spoilers' letter is as hilariously brutal as you'd expect
We asked linguists if Donald Trump speaks like that on purposeFelix the cat just raised £5000 for charity because she's the hero we all need
LONDON -- Remember Felix, the Huddersfield train station cat who got promoted to Senior Pest Control
...[详细]Black men arrested at Philadelphia Starbucks got the most inspiring settlement possible
The two men involved in a racial bias incident at Starbucks on April 12 have reached a settlement wi
...[详细]Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively troll each other on Twitter again
Turns out, even years after Gossip Girl, Blake Lively has some secrets up her sleeve — and her
...[详细]Roseanne Barr says she 'begged' ABC not to cancel her show
She's tweeting again.Roseanne Barr has dominated the news cycle this week after tweeting a racist ti
...[详细]Plane makes emergency landing after engine rips apart during flight
A Southwest Airlines flight bound for Orlando, Florida, made an emergency landing Saturday morning d
...[详细]4 tips for opening up about your mental health, from Lady Gaga's mom
Editor's note: Cynthia Germanotta runs the Born This Way Foundation with her daughter Stefani, who p
...[详细]The stigma against oatmeal raisin cookies must end
No matter how hard it tries, no matter how many recipe formations it attempts to squeeze into, it se
...[详细]Chrissy Teigen shares adorable tweet announcing the birth of her second child
Chrissy Teigen must be some kind of superhuman.SEE ALSO:19 times Chrissy Teigen got hilariously angr
...[详细]Nancy Pelosi warns colleagues after info hacked
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi warned fellow Democrats on Saturday to change their cellphone num
...[详细]Extreme 2016 Arctic heat wave stoked by climate change and low sea ice
Just days before Christmas in 2016, the North Pole was 50 degrees above its usual winter temperature
...[详细]Carlos Beltran made a very interesting hair choice
Chrissy Teigen teases John Legend for ditching their newborn — and gets real about postpartum life
