A seven-second self-driving Tesla video posted to Twitter this past weekend shows a likely illegal driving event in San Francisco that, unfortunately, happens all the time in ordinary situations. It’s the poster’s reaction that has left many online unsettled.
Tweet may have been deleted
In the video, we watch from inside the car’s cabin as the robo-Tesla edges close to a pedestrian who enters an intersection. The software display clearly shows the software picking up on the presence of the completely unprotected and vulnerable human, but Tesla’s software, it appears, doesn’t trigger compliance with the relevant law that says cars have to yield to pedestrians.
The text of the tweet couldn’t be more jolly about the victimless (in this case) moving violation, calling it "One of the most bullish / exciting things I've seen on Tesla Full Self-Driving Beta 11.4.1," and describes not yielding as proceeding "like a human would," rather than “slamming on the brakes."
SEE ALSO:Tesla's fastest-ever Model S gets tested in Top Gear videoWhole Mars Catalog, which posted the video, is the online identity of a Tesla and SpaceX fan apparently named Omar Qazi. The Whole Mars Catalog Twitter account has hundreds of thousands of followers, and draws approving replies from Elon Musk.
For a rundown of this not-at-all obscure law, check out the third second of the video, in which a sign can be seen which says "STATE LAW YIELD TO [PICTURE OF PEDESTRIAN] WITHIN CROSSWALK," just to the right of the pedestrian in the crosswalk not being yielded to.
Elon Musk recently touted the latest update to Tesla Full Self-Driving beta, version 11.4.1, as a steep improvement. It’s been slowly rolling out to Tesla consumers this month, and It’s supposedly so good that it should be called version 12, except that 12 will, Musk claims, be the release of an "end-to-end AI" version of FSD, whatever that means.
The video has some Twitter users concerned:
Tweet may have been deleted
Tweet may have been deleted
The Whole Mars Catalog Twitter account is, so far, full-throated in its defense of FSD 11.4.1, claiming that "people who don't live in cities aren't getting this," and that prior FSD updates would have caused the Tesla in question to stop within the crosswalk in this scenario. "That is wrong, continuing forward is right," claims Whole Mars Catalog. Indeed, stopping within a crosswalk blocks it, and no, that isn’t safe for pedestrians. The issue, however, is that this Tesla quite clearly has ample time to stop well before the crosswalk.
That a California driver may well also ignore the law in a similar situation is irrefutable (the author of this article is a reluctant Los Angeles driver). However, whether or not we should program our robotic cars to also drive this way should, perhaps, be a matter for public debate, and, maybe, for the legal system to decide. Such a democratically-informed decision could perhaps be made before this new norm is rolled out as a software update, and exuberantly lapped up by fans of a billionaire who then get to experiment with it on public roads.
TopicsTesla
(责任编辑：知識)
Make money or go to Stanford? Katie Ledecky is left with an unfair choice.
Hertz orders 100,000 Teslas to build the largest EV rental fleet in the U.S.
Iceland makes fun of Facebook's metaverse with the 'Icelandverse'
Cadillac's next luxury concept is a self
Give your kitchen sponge a rest on this adorable bedHow Hyperloop One went off the rails
In December 2014, an engineer with the unlikely name Brogan BamBrogan was in the driveway of his cla
...[详细]Iceland makes fun of Facebook's metaverse with the 'Icelandverse'
Facebook — sorry, Meta —CEO Mark Zuckerberg says his company is building an immersive wo
...[详细]How to use BeReal, an app asking you to stop curating your social media
When it comes to the vast pool of social sharing apps at our disposal, one trait is overwhelmingly c
...[详细]Everything coming to Amazon Prime Video in November
The Wheel of Time turns and brings us into November, ushering in a new slate of Amazon Prime origina
...[详细]Slack goes down again, prompting anxiety everywhere
Panic briefly took over on Tuesday when everyone's favorite messaging app/millstone went down tempor
...[详细]Apple Music's new 'Voice Plan' is cheaper, but you have to use Siri
Typing now costs extra. Apple announced a new Apple Music subscription tier dubbed the Voice Plan at
...[详细]'The Last Duel’s most shocking element is a defiant sense of humor
On its surface, The Last Duellooks like a prestige drama perfectly suited to Oscar season. It’
...[详细]Sesame Street will debut the first Asian American muppet in Thanksgiving special
Sesame Street and its educational nonprofit, Sesame Workshop, is set to throw the welcome party of a
...[详细]Is Samsung's Galaxy Note7 really the best phone?
On this week's 。 MashTalk 。, Lance, Pete and I talk about the new hot smartphone in town: Samsung's Ga
...[详细]How to use Waze and Google Maps to find cheaper gas
You can set your destination to cheaper gas with the help of Waze and Google Maps. The U.S. national
...[详细]Pole vaulter claims his penis is not to blame
Fierce cyclone deluges the West Coast, satellite footage shows
