In a historic 6-3 decision on June 24, the Supreme Court voted to overturn Roe v. Wade, eliminating the constitutional right to abortion. Soon after the decision was announced, a worried call to action quickly arose online: Delete your period tracking apps.
Tweet may have been deleted
It's not the first time this sentiment has bubbled up on the internet. Earlier this year, when the Supreme Court leak warned us of the decision to come, the same message spread across Twitter, TikTok, Instagram, and more. Women and people with uteruses who rely on these apps to monitor their health were suddenly fearful of how their collected data could be used against them in a hypothetical criminal case about abortion. With this latest Supreme Court decision — and Judge Thomas's call to the court to further examine precedent-setting right-to-privacy cases like Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell — that hypothetical seems a lot more possible.
iRobot Roomba Combo i3+ Self-Emptying Robot Vacuum and Mop—$329.99(List Price $599.99)
Samsung Galaxy Tab A9+ 10.9" 64GB Wi-Fi Tablet—$178.99(List Price $219.99)
Apple AirPods Pro 2nd Gen With MagSafe USB-C Charging Case—$189.99(List Price $249.00)
Eero 6 Dual-Band Mesh Wi-Fi 6 System (Router + 2 Extenders)—$149.99(List Price $199.99)
Apple Watch Series 9 (GPS, 41mm, Midnight, S/M, Sports Band)—$299.00(List Price $399.00)
Here's what you need to know about the ways period tracking apps treat your data, and how that could affect your reproductive health care.
SEE ALSO:Your privacy is at risk now that Roe v. Wade has fallen, experts warnOn a typical period tracking app, users enter data like what day their flow started and stopped, how heavy it might be, and other bodily symptoms. The app then usually learns the user's patterns and helps to predict when their next period may come, when they might be most fertile, and if they've missed a period and should take a pregnancy test.
With the overturning of Roe v. Wade, activists and data privacy experts are concerned about how this data could be used to prove that someone may have had an abortion or was thinking about getting one.
While there is no current precedent for how this specific data would be handled in a criminal case, apps have generally cooperated with criminal investigations in the past, usually in cases against child exploitation. Thus, it matters greatly where each user is located and whether their state is one of the 26 "certain or likely" to legally ban abortions without Roe v. Wade. Some of these states had trigger laws waiting on the Roe v. Wade decision, meaning that abortion was outlawed immediately in some, and will be banned in as little as 30 days in others.
"Since the approach in many states will be to criminalize people for the acts or seeking or providing abortion services, it is key for people in those states to understand that a mobile device is essentially a tracking device," said Jackie Singh, former senior cybersecurity staffer on the Biden presidential campaign, to Mashable. "While most people tend to leave our Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and location services on all the time for convenience, and rarely use a VPN or other privacy-protecting software, people who may be newly prosecuted as criminals no longer have the luxury of behaving as entirely free and lawful citizens."
If you do live in a state where this data is at risk but want to continue to use your app, it's important to take a closer look at your specific app's history with data sharing, its privacy policy, and where it stores your data.
Popular free period tracking app Flo, which has 43 million active users, came under fire for data sharing last year, reaching a settlement with the Federal Trade Commission regarding allegations that the app didn't inform its users about where their data was being shared. In this case, the Wall Street Journalfound that Flo was informing Facebook every time its users indicated they had their period or were wanting to get pregnant.
While Flo did not admit any wrongdoing in the settlement, and insisted to NPR that it does not share health data with any third party, this investigation and settlement leaves room for doubt as to how the app's privacy practices are currently enforced, and how that may change when under the pressure of a criminal investigation. In response to Roe v. Wade's overturning, Flo released a statement saying that a new "anonymous mode" that removes personal identity from users' data is launching soon. It remains to be seen how this mode will work.
In response, many period app users are calling for others to switch to the free app Clue, a European company that currently has about 12 million users. According to the company's response to Roe v. Wade, any period health data it receives is extra secure due to its obligation to apply special protections to reproductive health data in keeping with European data privacy law. Clue promises its business model does not rely on selling data to third parties, and that any data collected is de-identified and encrypted. It's important to note, though, that Flo is also headquartered in London, where the same laws should have applied and seemingly failed.
Tweet may have been deleted
Tweet may have been deleted
"Because data is so lucrative, and data collection and user profiling are a core part of most apps' business models, few apps have any true, provable commitment to privacy, such as a transparency report that makes representations about the company's stance on data collection," said Singh. While her standards are high, Singh did point to apps like Drip and Euki as possible contenders for apps that "should keep women in blue states safe" due to their commitment to local data storage and refusal to allow third-party tracking. Singh suggests still using these only in blue states for an extra layer of protection against dragnet surveillance.
Andrea Ford, a research fellow at the University of Edinburgh, also recommended via NPR that users should pay attention to where their data is stored when choosing an app. If it's stored locally on your actual device, Evan Greer, director of the digital rights advocacy group Fight for the Future, tells NPR that a court would need a warrant to search your phone, which has "a much higher legal bar" to obtain than a subpoena. If it's stored in a cloud and owned by the company, a subpoena would suffice.
"Data stored in health apps prior to the SCOTUS decision probably doesn't pose much of a risk," said Singh. "However, I would caution people who menstruate to stop using any type of app to track their menstrual health if they have any expectation of having a presence in states which are expected to ban abortion. However, we obviously cannot anticipate how future legislation will impact us, so the safest thing is to stop digital tracking."
TopicsApps & SoftwarePrivacySupreme Court
(责任编辑：熱點)
Fiji wins first
Walmart and Chick
Everything coming to Netflix in December 2019
Everything coming to HBO Now in December 2019Ivanka Trump's unpaid interns share cringeworthy financial adviceMajor earthquake and multiple aftershocks rock central Italy
UPDATE: Aug. 25, 2016, 8:22 a.m. BST。 Death toll is now at least 247 dead: 190 in Rieti province and
...[详细]Apple's new Research app lets you enroll in 3 health studies
Apple launched a new app called Research, letting users enroll in three health studies: the Apple Wo
...[详细]Greta Thunberg once again schools Trump, who tried to use her as an impeachment distraction
Greta Thunberg may be Time's Person of the Year, but she should also be named Twitter's person of th
...[详细]How to track your period using iOS 13 on an iPhone or Apple Watch
I can confidently say there are few things worse than when your period hits unexpectedly, especially
...[详细]Nate Parker is finally thinking about the woman who accused him of rape
Nate Parker is getting a crash course in male privilege after, in his own words, not thinking about
...[详细]20 Thanksgiving horror stories to stress you out before the big day
Thanksgiving dinner is high-stakes. It's labor-intensive. And people have a lot of opinions about it
...[详细]Defiant Taku glacier, long resistant to warming, has started shrinking
Chris McNeil has journeyed to Alaska's sprawling Taku Glacier at least once a year for the last deca
...[详细]Chrissy Teigen had the perfect reaction to John Legend being crowned 'sexiest man alive'
Chrissy Teigen is already a successful model, TV star, author, and Twitter legend — but now sh
...[详细]Ivanka Trump's unpaid interns share cringeworthy financial advice
Ivanka Trump's interns have some questionable advice for students worried they can't afford an unpai
...[详细]Sarah Huckabee Sanders mocked Joe Biden's stutter in a tweet and got ratio'd to heck
The 432678th Democratic presidential candidate debate in Los Angeles wound up on Thursday night with
...[详细]
