There's a strange but predictable phenomenon today: Moments and conversations of actual significance get washed through the digital echo chamber so many times and with such velocity that, before too long, they resemble bizarro caricatures of the actual things they once were.
That's how a grassroots movement responding to the very real problem of police violence directed at people of color gets reduced to two sides yelling at one another: "Black lives matter!" "No, all lives matter!" "No, blacklives matter!"
SEE ALSO:If you're outraged about Brock Turner, you need to learn about Brian BanksAnd so it was that the national anthem protests NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick began silently staging before NFL games on Aug. 26 reached their inevitable bizarro point this Sunday. Headline coverage touted supermodel Kate Upton using social media to deem NFL players' statements "unacceptable."
The falcon has indeed strayed far from the falconer here. Let's cut through the noise a bit and tighten this thing back up.
Almost three weeks after Kaepernick went from backup quarterback to national lightning rod, here's a look at what's resulted from his initial silent statement-- the good, the idiotic and the ugly alike.
Teammate Eric Reid joins Kaepernick in taking a knee during the national anthem Monday night.Credit: Daniel Gluskoter/APWe aren't begrudging Upton's right to chime in on a national conversation. It's just that her opinion has zero relevance to the issues Kaepernick initially sought to spotlight -- that "there are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder."
Just as Kaepernick has every right to use his platform for protest, Upton has every right to use hers for criticism. But excessive, celebrity-fueled coverage of Upton's criticism doesn't raise the national discourse. It moves us further from the actual conversation.
SEE ALSO:Colin Kaepernick's unlikely journey from rising NFL star to activist athleteSo, too, do statements like those made by the Seattle Seahawks and Kansas City Chiefs this weekend. Each team locked arms during the national anthem in a tepid show of "unity" that appeared designed to mollify Kaepernick's critics as much as support his message. After some big talk, Seattle's statement fell flat. Marcus Peters of the Chiefs, however, brought the message back to its origin by holding a gloved fist aloft as his teammates locked arms.
Kaepernick is like those North Carolina bathrooms, in that how one feels about the issue itself has almost become ancillary. Declaring support or opposition isn't simply doing that; to have a stance on Kaepernick or North Carolina bathrooms is to declare allegiance to an entire set of identities and outlooks as an American -- and to reject just as many.
That's why emotions have run so high. That's why a Texas cigar store called "The Man Cave" is using a Kaepernick jersey as a doormat. That's why fans have filmed themselves burning Kaepernick jerseys, and why Kaepernick's jersey has become the NFL's hottest seller thanks to those who support his message. That's why Brandon Marshall of the Denver Broncos lost two endorsement deals after joining the ongoing protest Kaepernick started.
That's why a backup quarterback has become the NFL's most-discussed player so far this season.
It's hard not to see battle lines being drawn, if only symbolically. The San Francisco 49ers, Kaepernick's team, announced last week a $1 million charity donation to organizations that address racial inequality. Around the same time, the Green Bay Packers donated $100,000 to a local police foundation.
But perhaps both donations drive home the same point.
Kaepernick warms up before the 49ers game Monday night.Credit: /Marcio Jose Sanchez/APFar from being banished to some activist-athlete island, Kaepernick has been joined in protest by players around the league. American soccer star Megan Rapinoe, too, made a powerful statement of support in early September by kneeling herself -- even if other white athletes have been reluctant to follow suit.
Now even high school football players across the country can be spotted dropping to one knee during pregame national anthems. Not even the ol' Friday night high school football game can escape this political moment.
A statement commonly paraphrased from a Karl Marx quote says "Religion is the opium of the people." The German philosopher's point way back in the mid 19th Century was that so many people immerse themselves in religion as a way to avoid the pain and tough decisions of real life. In America today, it doesn't take much imagination to replace "religion" with "sports and other entertainment genres" and still have Marx's ancient idea ring searingly true. (A reality TV star is one election away from the presidency, for crying out loud.)
Sports, for so many, represent a retreat and reprieve from real life. Kaepernick has now pierced that bubble, which angers many fans and has them burning his jersey or using it as a public doormat. Sports fans have been forced to consider some things outside of sports, and the results they've found are uncomfortably ugly.
That's why, in part, so many are so mad. And that's why -- despite the media circus that's since sprung up around him -- Kaepernick has already won.
(责任编辑:焦點)
This app is giving streaming TV news a second try
The District of Columbia is suing Grubhub for hidden fees, misleading advertising, and more
Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for April 21
Google now lets you search with an image and text at the same time
The five guys who climbed Australia's highest mountain, in swimwearOlympian celebrates by ordering an intimidating amount of McDonald's
It's no secret that Olympians have to eat clean for years to ensure they're at peak physical conditi
...[详细]'Prospect' filmmakers to launch NFT collection to fund sci
Ever felt like you know a movie franchise so well that you'd be able to take it in a better directio
...[详细]Ukraine is legalising the cryptocurrency market
Ukraine will soon legally recognise cryptocurrency, after President Volodymyr Zelenskyy signed a vir
...[详细]NASA Artemis rocket launch rehearsal delayed
Artemis I, the first in a series of increasingly complex NASA missions aimed at making human explora
...[详细]Dramatic photo captures nun texting friends after Italy earthquake
The image of an injured, bloodied nun, calmly texting friends and family in the wake of the deadly e
...[详细]Poet Amanda Gorman teaches Sesame Street's Grover a new word
On Monday, poet Amanda Gorman taught Sesame Street's Grover about a new word, "upstander."Gorman is
...[详细]Google I/O dates announced for May
Tech conferences are back, baby. Sort of. That's according to Google, which on Wednesday announced t
...[详细]Air fryer breakfast cookies are super easy to make and pretty healthy
I'll be upfront: I am not a sweet breakfast person. Most days my breakfast is a fried egg on a corn
...[详细]There's a big piece of fake chicken stuck to this phone case
If the perfect smartphone case signals a bit about who its owner is, then this silicon fried chicken
...[详细]Apple Fitness Plus now includes exercise for postpartum parents
After giving birth, postpartum exercise is something that should be navigated consciously and safely
...[详细]One of the most controversial power struggles in media comes to a close

TikTok suspends livestreams in Russia a day after its 'state
