If you ask nearly all the world's climate scientists, there's simply no debate: The planet is warming as amounts of greenhouse gases rise in the air -- and human activity is primarily to blame.
But Scott Pruitt, head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, insists on debating climate change. And that debate, apparently, might be televised, Reuters reported on Tuesday.
SEE ALSO:Antarctic ice shelf crack is moving at record speeds, poised to cleave off massive iceberg any minuteDoubters of mainstream climate science, including Pruitt, argue that dissenting views haven't been heard by the scientific community. They falsely claim that plenty of questions still remain about the scientific evidence for human-caused global warming.
In reality, however, while there is uncertainty about how quickly and severely rising temperatures will affect the planet, there's virtually no doubt among climate scientists that climate change is happening -- and that it's happening because of us.
Credit: NASA GISSBy calling for a debate, Pruitt creates a false narrative that casts his critics as stubborn, inflexible bullies who are hell-bent on destroying the fossil fuel industry. In this scenario, climate scientists and their allies are jealously guarding the climate discussion. Why don't other folks, like coal company executives, get to have a say?
Rather than inform the public, all this does is cast clouds of distrust and disbelief over the scientific community. That's why climate scientists say calls for such debates are disconcerting: According to the Trump administration, satellite observations, ground measurements, field research, and deeply scrutinized results -- gathered over decades and from across the globe -- simply aren't sufficiently convincing.
In the interview with Reuters, Pruitt called for a "robust discussion" about climate change, though he didn't explain how the scientists participating in that discussion would be chosen.
Asked if the debate should be televised, Pruitt told Reuters: "I think so. I think so. I mean, I don’t know yet, but you want this to be open to the world. You want this to be on full display. I think the American people would be very interested in consuming that. I think they deserve it."
Credit: Ed HawkinsThe TV debate would likely build on or coincide with the Trump administration's plans to host so-called "red team, blue team" debates on climate science.
Pruitt, who denies that carbon dioxide is the main cause of global warming (it is), would reportedly help pick the experts. He's floated the idea in recent weeks, saying such discussions would be modeled on processes used for evaluating military battle plans and ways that spacecraft engineers test critical systems or investigate accidents.
Many climate scientists said they see this plan as a direct assault on the scientific process. Looping in non-experts to debate climate science would be like asking a person who likes looking at the stars to go head-to-head with actual astronomers and physicists.
"It's one thing to respond to legitimate scientific criticism, quite another to refute unconstrained nonsense," Kate Marvel, a scientist at NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York, previously told Mashable.
TopicsDonald Trump
(责任编辑：知識)
What brands need to know about virtual reality
Disney and Marvel can use all of Netflix's Defenders now. Should they?
A complete history of Keyboard Cat, the meme that won't be played offDisney and Marvel can use all of Netflix's Defenders now. Should they?Airbnb activates disaster response site for Louisiana floodingCat gets stuck in the most awkward position ever
Anyone with a cat can tell you that although their cat's claws are impressive scratching and hunting
...[详细]Mastercard will support cryptocurrency payments this year
Financial services company Mastercard has given fresh credibility to cryptocurrencies this week by a
...[详细]Twitter is now adding a controversial 'hacked materials' warning label to tweets
“These materials may have been obtained through hacking,” reads the disclaimer affixed t
...[详细]China's Tianwen1 probe beams back a fresh look at the planet Mars
China has almost reached the red planet.The Chinese probe Tianwen-1 is just days away from entering
...[详细]Fyvush Finkel, Emmy winner for 'Picket Fences,' dies at 93
NEW YORK (AP) — Actor Fyvush Finkel, the plastic-faced Emmy Award-winning character actor whos
...[详细]TikTok's first user to hit 100 million followers is Charli D'Amelio
Charli D'Amelio's meteoric rise on TikTok just hit a milestone that no one else has so far: 100 mill
...[详细]Twitter meme identifies things that feel racist, but technically aren't
What's something that ISN'T a joke but still FEELS like a joke to you?A new Twitter meme has users l
...[详细]A complete history of Keyboard Cat, the meme that won't be played off
In Tales of the Early Internet, Mashable explores online life through 2007 — back before socia
...[详细]This coloring book is here for all your relationship goals
LONDON -- We are living through the golden age of celebrity relationships. Gone are the days of tort
...[详细]How Facebook, Twitter, YouTube responded to Trump's lies
When it rained misinformation during election season, it poured policy updates from tech platforms.
...[详细]Researchers create temporary tattoos you can use to control your devices
Take the confusion out of reporting abuse, online harassment with this app
